42nd Street
Fifth UK Tour
May 4, 2007 (Matinee)
Jessica Punch (Peggy Sawyer), Ashley Nottingham (Billy Lawlor), Julia J. Nagle (Dorothy Brock), Paul Nicholas (Julian Marsh), Shirley Jameson (Maggie Jones), Graham Hoadly (Bert Barry), Graeme Henderson (Andy Lee), Nicholas Charters (Pat Denning), Bruce Montague (Abner Dillon), Rebecca Marks (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Danielle Corlass (Lorraine Flemming), Sarah Thornton (Phyllis Dale)
Trading notes: Recorded from Front Row, Stalls
September 21, 2007 (Evening)
Lisa Dent (u/s Peggy Sawyer), Ashley Nottingham (Billy Lawlor), Julia J. Nagle (Dorothy Brock), Tim Flavin (Julian Marsh), Shirley Jameson (Maggie Jones), Graham Hoadly (Bert Barry), Graeme Henderson (Andy Lee), Nicholas Charters (Pat Denning), Bruce Montague (Abner Dillon), Rebecca Marks (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Danielle Corlass (Lorraine Flemming), Sarah Thornton (Phyllis Dale)
Trading notes: Lisas first (and possibly only) show as Peggy Sawyer
October 31, 2007 (Matinee)
Jessica Punch (Peggy Sawyer), Ashley Nottingham (Billy Lawlor), Julia J. Nagle (Dorothy Brock), Stephen McGann (Julian Marsh), Shirley Jameson (Maggie Jones), Graham Hoadly (Bert Barry), Graeme Henderson (Andy Lee), Nicholas Charters (Pat Denning), Bruce Montague (Abner Dillon), Rebecca Marks (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Danielle Corlass (Lorraine Flemming), Sarah Thornton (Phyllis Dale)
October 31, 2007 (Evening)
Jessica Punch (Peggy Sawyer), Ashley Nottingham (Billy Lawlor), Julia J. Nagle (Dorothy Brock), Stephen McGann (Julian Marsh), Shirley Jameson (Maggie Jones), Graham Hoadly (Bert Barry), Graeme Henderson (Andy Lee), Nicholas Charters (Pat Denning), Bruce Montague (Abner Dillon), Rebecca Marks (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Danielle Corlass (Lorraine Flemming), Sarah Thornton (Phyllis Dale)
November 10, 2007 (Evening)
Jessica Punch (Peggy Sawyer), Ashley Nottingham (Billy Lawlor), Julia J. Nagle (Dorothy Brock), Stephen McGann (Julian Marsh), Shirley Jameson (Maggie Jones), Graham Hoadly (Bert Barry), Cameron Ball (u/s Andy Lee), Nicholas Charters (Pat Denning), Bruce Montague (Abner Dillon), Rebecca Marks (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Kirsty Lee Turner (u/s Lorraine Flemming), Sarah Thornton (Phyllis Dale)
November 24, 2007 (Matinee)
Jessica Punch (Peggy Sawyer), Ashley Nottingham (Billy Lawlor), Julia J. Nagle (Dorothy Brock), Stephen McGann (Julian Marsh), Shirley Jameson (Maggie Jones), Graham Hoadly (Bert Barry), Graeme Henderson (Andy Lee), Nicholas Charters (Pat Denning), Bruce Montague (Abner Dillon), Rebecca Marks (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Danielle Corlass (Lorraine Flemming), Sarah Thornton (Phyllis Dale)
Sixth UK Tour
July 18, 2012 (Matinee)
Jessica Punch (Peggy Sawyer), James O'Connell (Billy Lawlor), Marti Webb (Dorothy Brock), Dave Willetts (Julian Marsh)
The Muny
June 29, 2016 (Evening)
Jonalyn Saxer (Peggy Sawyer), Jay Armstrong Johnson (Billy Lawlor), Emily Skinner (Dorothy Brock), Shuler Hensley (Julian Marsh), Ann Harada (Maggie Jones), Jason Kravits (Bert Barry), Bryan Thomas Hunt (Andy Lee), Joey Sorge (Pat Denning), Fred Zimmerman (Abner Dillon), Megan Sikora (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Rich Pisarkiewicz (Oscar)
Goodspeed Musicals Revival
November 6, 2022 (Evening)
Carina-Kay Louchiey (Peggy Sawyer), Blake Stadnik (Billy Lawlor), Kate Baldwin (Dorothy Brock), Max von Essen (Julian Marsh), Lisa Howard (Maggie Jones), E. Clayton Cornelious (Bert Barry), Lamont Brown (Andy Lee), Patrick Oliver Jones (Pat Denning), David Jennings (Abner Dillon), Eloise Kropp (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Christopher Shin (Ensemble), Christian Probst (Ensemble), Brady Miller (Ensemble), Brian Shimasaki Liebson (Ensemble), Taylor Lane (Ensemble), Edward Juvier (Ensemble), Danielle Jackman (Ensemble), Candice Hatakeyama (Ensemble), Berklea Going (Ensemble), Sarah Dearstyne (Ensemble), Willie Clyde Beaton II (Ensemble)
Trading notes: Closing performance. There was a child in front of me who talked and moved around a bit but shouldnt be too distracting. Sweet show.
Lexington Theatre Company
July 10, 2025 (Evening)
Elizabeth McGuire (Peggy Sawyer), Griffin Wilkins (Billy Lawlor), Kristen Beth Williams (Dorothy Brock), Ron Bohmer (Julian Marsh), Karyn Czar (Maggie Jones), Brance Cornelius (Bert Barry), Ari'el Chaim Barmor (Andy Lee), Matthew Belopavlovich (Pat Denning), Tim X Davis (Abner Dillon), Dan Klimko (Mac), Caroline Lynch Desmarais (Ann "Anytime Annie" Reilly), Melissa Lynne Jones (Lorraine Flemming), Jess Zylstra (Phyllis Dale), Abby Hesselroth (Diane Lorimar), Molly Munn (Ethel), Andy Beshear (g/p Doctor), Matt Guernier (Ensemble), Chase Fontenot (Ensemble), John Kearney (Ensemble), Erin Klocke (Ensemble), Madison Knapp (Ensemble), Miller Jay Kraps (Ensemble), Nate Krohmer (Ensemble), Caroline Morrison (Ensemble), Fiona Mowbray (Ensemble), Ella Ciuro (Ensemble), Marc Pavan (Ensemble), David Benjamin Perry (Ensemble), Abigayle Kate Gatton Stokes (Ensemble), Melanie Becker (Ensemble)
Master's notes: Opening night! Super fun surprise as Democratic Governor of Kentucky Andy Beshear was in the audience, and has a surprise walk-on role in act two as the doctor! As far as I know, it’s Andy’s stage debut!