Big Fish
Broadway
September 5, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Norbert Leo Butz (Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill), Zachary Unger (Young Will), Ben Crawford (Don Price / Red Fang), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water), Robin Campbell (Ensemble), Leah Hofmann (Ensemble), Lara Seibert Young (Ensemble), Cary Tedder (Ensemble), Tally Sessions (Ensemble), Angie Schworer (Ensemble), Jason Lee Garrett (Ensemble), Bryn Dowling (Ensemble), Bree Branker (Ensemble)
Trading notes: First Preview. All songs, tracked
September 5, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Norbert Leo Butz (Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom / Story Sandra), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill / Story Jenny), Zachary Unger (Young Will), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water)
Trading notes: First Preview on Broadway.
September 7, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Norbert Leo Butz (Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom / Story Sandra), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill / Story Jenny), Zachary Unger (Young Will), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water)
September 10, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Norbert Leo Butz (Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom / Story Sandra), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill / Story Jenny), Zachary Unger (Young Will), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water)
September 21, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Norbert Leo Butz (Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom / Story Sandra), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill / Story Jenny), Zachary Unger (Young Will), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water)
September 25, 2013 (Matinee)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Norbert Leo Butz (Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill), Anthony Pierini (alt Young Will), Ben Crawford (Don Price), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water), Tally Sessions (Mayor), Robin Campbell (Alabama Lamb), Lara Seibert Young (Alabama Lamb), Bryn Dowling (Dancing Fire), Angie Schworer (Josephine's Doctor), Bree Branker (Ensemble), Jason Lee Garrett (Ensemble), Leah Hofmann (Ensemble), Cary Tedder (Ensemble)
October 9, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Ben Crawford (u/s Edward Bloom), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill), Zachary Unger (Young Will), Preston Truman Boyd (u/s Don Price / u/s Red Fang), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water), Robin Campbell (Ensemble), Leah Hofmann (Ensemble), Lara Seibert Young (Ensemble), Cary Tedder (Ensemble), Tally Sessions (Ensemble), Angie Schworer (Ensemble), Jason Lee Garrett (Ensemble), Bryn Dowling (Ensemble), Bree Branker (Ensemble)
Trading notes: Ben and Prestons first time doing the full show in their respective roles. Both went on for the second act during the matinee.
October 9, 2013 (Evening)
Bobby Steggert (Will Bloom), Ben Crawford (u/s Edward Bloom / u/s Story Edward), Ciara Renée (The Witch), Brad Oscar (Amos Calloway), Kate Baldwin (Sandra Bloom / Story Sandra), Kirsten Scott (Jenny Hill / Story Jenny), Zachary Unger (Young Will), Preston Truman Boyd (u/s Don Price), J.C. Montgomery (Dr. Bennett), Krystal Joy Brown (Josephine Bloom), Alex Brightman (Zacky Price), Ryan Andes (Karl the Giant), Sarrah Strimel (Girl in the Water)
Trading notes: Ben’s first show as Edward.
Off-West End
November 6, 2017 (Evening)
Matthew Seadon-Young (Will Bloom), Kelsey Grammer (Edward Bloom), Landi Oshinowo (The Witch / Jenny Hill), Forbes Masson (Amos Calloway / Don Price), Clare Burt (Sandra Bloom), Jonathan Stewart (Dr. Bennett), Frances McNamee (Josephine Bloom), George Ure (Zacky Price), Dean Nolan (Karl the Giant), Laura Baldwin (Story Sandra), Tanisha Spring (Story Jenny), Jamie Muscato (Story Edward), Sophie Linder-Lee (Mermaid / Librarian), Gemma McMeel (Girl with Cat / Peggy), Colby Mulgrew (Boy)
Lyric Arts
September 14, 2025
Will Gaspar (Will Bloom), Ben Bakken (Edward Bloom), Imani Harris (The Witch), Justin Betancourt (Amos Calloway), Kate Beahen (Sandra Bloom), Megan Beard 2 (Jenny Hill), Kaden Hesser (Young Will), Jonah Dale Matias Anderson (Young Will), James Ehlenz (Don Price), Margaret Reid (Dr. Bennett), Lydia Rose Prior (Josephine Bloom), Alex Stokes (Zacky Price), Brandon Osero (Karl the Giant), Sarah Christenson (Girl in the Water), Finnola Coughlin (Ensemble), James Grace (Ensemble), Jonathan P. Haller (Ensemble), Brooklyn Klekamp (Ensemble), Catherine Maki (Ensemble), Drew Reynhout (Ensemble), Tim Wollman (Ensemble)