Finding Neverland
Pre-Broadway / American Repertory Theater
July 24, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Mary Page Nance (Servant)
Trading notes: Act 1 is very squeaky for some reason, the audio is still clear-ish though and you can still hear the songs and cast. Act 2 is perfect!
July 25, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Mary Page Nance (Servant)
Trading notes: Third preview. Act 2 cuts early.
July 28, 2014
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies)
Trading notes: Act 2 only.
July 31, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Courtney Balan (Miss Jones), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Stuart Neal (Elliott), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Rory Donovan (Mr. Turpin), Dana Costello (Miss Potter), Thayne Jasperson (Porthos), Ron Todorowski (Servant), JC Schuster (Servant), Mary Page Nance (Servant)
August 2, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Courtney Balan (Miss Jones), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Stuart Neal (Elliott), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Rory Donovan (Mr. Turpin), Dana Costello (Miss Potter), Thayne Jasperson (Porthos), Mary Page Nance (Servant), Ron Todorowski (Servant), Julius Anthony Rubio (s/w Servant)
August 3, 2014 (Matinee)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Courtney Balan (Miss Jones), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Stuart Neal (Elliott), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Rory Donovan (Mr. Turpin), Dana Costello (Miss Potter), Thayne Jasperson (Porthos), Mary Page Nance (Servant), JC Schuster (Servant), Ron Todorowski (Servant)
August 16, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies)
August 19, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Courtney Balan (Miss Jones), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Stuart Neal (Elliott), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Rory Donovan (Mr. Turpin), Dana Costello (Miss Potter), Thayne Jasperson (Porthos), Ron Todorowski (Servant), Mary Page Nance (Servant), JC Schuster (Servant)
September 2, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier)
September 28, 2014 (Evening)
Jeremy Jordan (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Michael McGrath (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Jeanna de Waal (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Courtney Balan (Miss Jones), Gaelen Gilliland (Miss Bassett), Stuart Neal (Elliott), Emma Sofia (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Rory Donovan (Mr. Turpin), Dana Costello (Miss Potter), Thayne Jasperson (Porthos), JC Schuster (Servant), Ron Todorowski (Servant), Mary Page Nance (Servant)
Trading notes: Closing Night of the Pre-Broadway run with Jeremy Jordan.
Broadway
November 10, 2015 (Evening, 2)
Matthew Morrison (J.M. Barrie), Dana Costello (u/s Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Terrence Mann (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Courtney Balan (u/s Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Eli Tokash (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Christian Michael Camporin (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Alex Dreier (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Casey Butler (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Heather Parcells (u/s Miss Jones), Jessica Vosk (Miss Bassett), Chris Dwan (Elliott), Jonathan Ritter (Albert), Emma Sofia (Emily)
Trading notes: Includes BC/EFA Speech by Colin Cunliffe.
First US National Tour
July 1, 2017
Billy Harrigan Tighe (J.M. Barrie), Christine Dwyer (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Will Ray (Captain James Hook / Ensemble), John Davidson (Captain James Hook / Charles Frohman), Kristine Reese (Mary Barrie), Colin Wheeler (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Tyler Patrick Hennessy (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Turner Birthisel (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Bergman Freedman (George Llewelyn Davies), Dee Tomasetta (Peter Pan), Matt Wolpe (Mr. Cromer), Dwelvan David (Mr. Henshaw), Matthew Quinn (u/s Lord Cannan), Caitlyn Caughell (Miss Jones), Sarah Marie Charles (Miss Bassett), Connor McRory (u/s Elliott), Adrianne Chu (Wendy / Ensemble), Corey Rives (Albert / Ensemble)
Master's notes: A great performance of the tour, which was significantly changed from the Broadway production of the show. Billy & Christine are standouts. Released April 2026.