Water for Elephants
Broadway
February 24, 2024 (Evening)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Charles South (Ensemble), Marissa Rosen (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Ensemble), Paul Castree (Ensemble), Rachael Boyd (Ensemble), Antoine Boissereau (Ensemble)
Trading notes: First preview. Very energized audience. A lot of the mid-song applause is due to the accompanying circus acts. A funny mishap in one of the last scenes when an ensemble member enters early, then has to re-enter at the correct time prompting the whole audience to laugh and Gregg Edelman to improv a bit.
March 3, 2024 (Evening)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade)
Trading notes: 9th grade Lia who watched the Flash every single day in english class instead of paying attention was thriving. They didn’t let Grant do his silly little tap dancing nearly enough. The audio is pure iPhone quality so basically… ehhhhhh little fuzzy but also not horrible.
March 10, 2024 (Matinee)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Charles South (Ensemble), Marissa Rosen (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Ensemble), Paul Castree (Ensemble), Rachael Boyd (s/w Ensemble), Antoine Boissereau (Ensemble)
March 12, 2024 (Evening)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Harley McLeish (s/w Ensemble), Rachael Boyd (s/w Ensemble), Brandon Block (s/w Ensemble), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Charles South (Ensemble), Marissa Rosen (Ensemble), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Ensemble), Paul Castree (Ensemble), Antoine Boissereau (Ensemble)
Trading notes: Excellent show! People are hating on some aspects of the show, especially the score and puppetry. I will say, there isn’t really a standout number in the show, which makes the music feel a bit bland. But I thought it was brilliant how the animals were conveyed through a mix of puppetry and acrobatics. Don’t believe the negative reviews and please go see it for yourself if you are able! Very enjoyable show.
March 14, 2024 (Evening)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade)
March 20, 2024 (Evening)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Charles South (Ensemble), Marissa Rosen (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Ensemble), Paul Castree (Ensemble), Rachael Boyd (Ensemble), Antoine Boissereau (Ensemble)
March 30, 2024 (Matinee)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena / June), Paul Alexander Nolan (August / Charlie), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Marissa Rosen (Sue), Michael Mendez (Caretaker), Taylor Colleton (Vera), Paul Castree (Orderly / Sal), Alexandra Gaelle Royer (Agnes), Antoine Boissereau (Silver Star), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Rex), Caroline Kane (Nurse Rosemary), Charles South (Worker), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble)
Master's notes: Includes Isabelle's BCEFA speech.
April 2024 (Matinee)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Charles South (Ensemble), Marissa Rosen (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Ensemble), Paul Castree (Ensemble), Rachael Boyd (Ensemble), Antoine Boissereau (Ensemble)
May 28, 2024 (Evening)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena / June), Paul Alexander Nolan (August / Charlie), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Michelle West (s/w Sue), Michael Mendez (Caretaker), Taylor Colleton (Vera), Paul Castree (Orderly / Sal), Alexandra Gaelle Royer (Agnes), Antoine Boissereau (Silver Star), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Rex), Caroline Kane (Nurse Rosemary), Charles South (Worker), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Isabella Luisa Diaz (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble)
Trading notes: audio ends halfway through the curtain call.
May 29, 2024 (Matinee)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Michelle West (s/w Sue)
Master's notes: Not for sale. Please do not post ANY part of this recording on ANY social media platform (including, but not limited to TikTok, tumblr, Youtube etc.)
June 23, 2024 (Matinee)
Grant Gustin (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Samantha Gershman (u/s Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Michael Mendez (Ensemble), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Sean Stack (Ensemble), Charles South (Ensemble), Alexandra Gaelle Royer (Ensemble), Marissa Rosen (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Ensemble), Paul Castree (Ensemble), Rachael Boyd (s/w Ensemble), Antoine Boissereau (Ensemble), Brandon Block (s/w Ensemble)
Trading notes: Includes video of bows
September 14, 2024 (Evening)
Kyle Selig (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August / Charlie), Asa Somers (Camel), Philippe Aymard (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Marissa Rosen (Sue / Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Caretaker / Rosie / Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Vera / Ensemble), Sean Stack (Rosie), Caroline Kane (Rosie / Nurse Rosemary / Ensemble), Charles South (Rosie / Worker), Paul Castree (Rosie / Sal / Worker / Ensemble), Alexandra Gaelle Royer (Agnes), Antoine Boissereau (Silver Star), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Rex), Conor Wild (Ensemble), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Marina Mendoza (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble)
Master's notes: This show is something to see live. The music is not my favorite, however, the acrobatics make up for it. It is a true spectacle, highly recommend it in person.
Trading notes: Never publicly post, gift/trade as you see fit.
September 14, 2024 (Matinee)
Kyle Selig (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena), Paul Alexander Nolan (August / Charlie), Asa Somers (u/s Camel), Philippe Aymard (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Marissa Rosen (Sue / Ensemble), Michael Mendez (Caretaker / Rosie / Ensemble), Taylor Colleton (Vera / Ensemble), Paul Castree (Rosie / Sal / Worker / Ensemble), Caroline Kane (Rosie / Nurse Rosemary / Ensemble), Sean Stack (Rosie), Charles South (Rosie / Worker), Alexandra Gaelle Royer (Agnes), Antoine Boissereau (Silver Star), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Rex), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Marina Mendoza (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble), Matthew Varvar (Ensemble), Conor Wild (Ensemble)
October 20, 2024 (Matinee)
Kyle Selig (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena / June), Paul Alexander Nolan (August / Charlie), Stan Brown (Camel), Philippe Aymard (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Marissa Rosen (Sue), Michael Mendez (Caretaker / Rosie), Taylor Colleton (Vera), Paul Castree (Orderly / Rosie / Sal), Charles South (Rosie / Worker), Matthew Varvar (u/s Rosie), Caroline Kane (Rosie / Nurse Rosemary), Meghane Poulet (s/w Agnes), Antoine Boissereau (Silver Star), Keaton Hentoff-Killian (u/s Rex), Brandon Block (Ensemble), Nicolas Jelmoni (Ensemble), Harley McLeish (Ensemble), Marina Mendoza (Ensemble), Samuel Renaud (Ensemble)
December 7, 2024 (Evening)
Kyle Selig (Jacob Jankowski), Gregg Edelman (Mr. Jankowski), Isabelle McCalla (Marlena / June), Paul Alexander Nolan (August / Charlie), Stan Brown (Camel), Joe De Paul (Walter), Sara Gettelfinger (Barbara), Wade McCollum (Wade), Marissa Rosen (Sue), Michael Mendez (Caretaker / Rosie), Taylor Colleton (Vera), Paul Castree (Orderly / Rosie / Sal), Caroline Kane (Rosie / Nurse Rosemary), Charles South (Rosie / Worker), Sean Stack (Rosie), Alexandra Gaelle Royer (Agnes), Antoine Boissereau (Silver Star), Gabriel Olivera De Paula Costa (Rex), Isabella Luisa Diaz (s/w Ensemble), Harley McLeish (s/w Ensemble)
Master's notes: Includes photos of cast board, playbill, and understudy slip.
Trading notes: Second to last performance on Broadway. Unsure which ensemble members Isabella Luisa Diaz and Harley McLeish were on for.
First US National Tour
October 16, 2025 (Evening)
Zachary Keller (Jacob Jankowski), Robert Tully (Mr. Jankowski), Helen Krushinski (Marlena), Connor Sullivan (August), Javier Garcia (Camel), Tyler West (Walter), Ruby Gibbs (Barbara), Grant Huneycutt (Wade)
May 3, 2026 (Matinee)
Zachary Keller (Jacob Jankowski), Robert Tully (Mr. Jankowski), Helen Krushinski (Marlena / June), Connor Sullivan (August / Charlie), Javier Garcia (Camel), Tyler West (Walter), Ruby Gibbs (Barbara), Chris Marth (Wade / Rosie), Yemie Woo (Sue / Kinker / Roust), John Neurohr (Caretaker / Rosie / Kinker / Roust), Zakeyia Lacey (Vera / Kinker / Roust), Carl Robinett (Orderly / Kinker / Roust), Bradley Parrish (Rosie / Sal / Worker / Kinker / Roust), Summer Severin (s/w Rosie / s/w Nurse Rosemary / s/w Kinker / s/w Roust), Meghane Poulet (Agnes / Kinker / Roust), Yves Artières (Silver Star / Kinker / Roust), Kayden Woodbridge (s/w Rex / s/w Kinker / s/w Roust), Fran Álvarez Jara (Kinker / Roust), Marina Mendoza (s/w Kinker / s/w Roust)
July 14, 2026 (Evening)
Zachary Keller (Jacob Jankowski), Robert Tully (Mr. Jankowski), Helen Krushinski (Marlena / June), Connor Sullivan (August / Charlie), Javier Garcia (Camel), Tyler West (Walter), Ruby Gibbs (Barbara), Grant Huneycutt (Wade), Yemie Woo (Sue / Kinker / Roust), John Neurohr (Caretaker / Rosie / Kinker / Roust), Zakeyia Lacey (Vera / Kinker / Roust), Andrew Meier (s/w Orderly / s/w Rosie / s/w Kinker / s/w Roust), Bradley Parrish (Rosie / Sal / Kinker / Roust), Ella Huestis (Rosie / Nurse Rosemary / Kinker / Roust), Gaby Diaz (Agnes / Kinker / Roust), Serafina Walker (Silver Star / Kinker / Roust), Kayden Woodbridge (s/w Rex / s/w Kinker / s/w Roust), José Martinez (Kinker / Roust), Yves Artières (Kinker / Roust), Adam Fullick (Kinker / Roust), Summer Severin (s/w Kinker / s/w Roust), Glenn Doyle (s/w Kinker / s/w Roust), Marina Mendoza (s/w Ensemble)
Master's notes: Great recording of the tour in Toronto. Some shuffling can be heard throughout.